Synthetic Securities
Category
Related Terms
Browse by Category
What Are Synthetic Securities?
Synthetic securities are financial instruments created artificially by combining other assets—such as cash, stocks, or derivatives—to simulate the cash flows and risk profile of a specific security without actually owning it.
If you want to invest in a bond issued by Company X, you normally just buy the bond. But what if there are no bonds for sale? Or what if you want the bond's return but in a different currency? Investment banks can create a "Synthetic Bond" for you. They might take a safe US Treasury bond (for the principal) and combine it with a Credit Default Swap (CDS) that pays out the yield of Company X. To you, the investor, it looks and acts like a bond from Company X. But legally, it is a bundle of contracts. This is a synthetic security. It is a financial simulation.
Key Takeaways
- They are "manufactured" assets that mimic "real" assets.
- Created to lower costs, gain access to restricted markets, or customize risk.
- Common examples include Synthetic CDOs and Asset Swaps.
- They rely heavily on derivatives and counterparty agreements.
- They played a notorious role in the 2008 Financial Crisis (Synthetic CDOs).
Why Create Them?
Synthetics solve specific market problems:
- Liquidity: Creating supply of an asset when the actual asset is scarce.
- Customization: Tailoring the maturity, currency, or yield to a client's exact needs.
- Regulatory Arbitrage: Getting around rules that ban owning certain assets (e.g., a fund that can't own derivatives might buy a "Note" that legally looks like a bond but acts like a derivative).
- Shorting: Easier to bet against an asset synthetically (buying a CDS) than shorting the physical bond.
The Synthetic CDO
The most infamous synthetic security is the Synthetic Collateralized Debt Obligation (CDO). In the mid-2000s, banks ran out of actual mortgages to package into bonds. So, they created Synthetic CDOs. These didn't contain real mortgages. They contained "bets" on mortgages (via CDS). It allowed the market to bet billions on the housing market without needing actual houses to back it up. When the housing market collapsed, these synthetic bets magnified the losses exponentially, nearly destroying the global financial system.
Real-World Example: Asset Swaps
A European investor wants to buy a US Corporate Bond yielding 5% in Dollars. However, they only have Euros and want a fixed return in Euros. The Bank creates a synthetic package: 1. Investor buys the US Bond. 2. Investor enters a Cross-Currency Asset Swap with the bank. * Investor gives the Bank the Dollar coupons. * Bank gives the Investor Euro coupons.
Risks
Synthetic securities introduce **Counterparty Risk**. If you buy a real stock, you own a piece of the company. If you buy a synthetic stock (e.g., a Total Return Swap) from a bank, you rely on the bank to pay you. If the bank fails, your "stock" becomes a claim in bankruptcy court.
FAQs
Some are. "Physical" ETFs hold the actual stocks or gold. "Synthetic" ETFs hold derivatives (swaps) with a bank to replicate the index return. Synthetic ETFs are common in Europe but less so in the US due to counterparty risk concerns.
Replication is the process of mimicking the performance of an index or asset. Physical replication buys the assets. Synthetic replication uses swaps and derivatives to achieve the same math result.
Yes, widely used by institutions. However, they are highly regulated, especially after 2008 (Dodd-Frank Act) to ensure transparency and capital reserves.
Rarely directly. Retail investors encounter them mostly through structured notes or synthetic ETFs. The underlying "plumbing" of these products is synthetic.
In theory, it spreads risk and adds liquidity. It allows investors who want exposure to mortgage credit risk to get it, even if no new mortgages are being originated. In practice, it created a casino of side-bets.
The Bottom Line
Synthetic securities are the ultimate expression of financial engineering. They detach the "financial return" from the "physical asset," allowing risk and reward to be sliced, diced, and repackaged in infinite ways. While they provide crucial flexibility for global banks and hedge funds, they add layers of complexity and interconnectedness to the system. For the prudent investor, understanding the difference between owning a "real" asset and a "synthetic" promise is the first step in risk management.
Related Terms
More in Derivatives
At a Glance
Key Takeaways
- They are "manufactured" assets that mimic "real" assets.
- Created to lower costs, gain access to restricted markets, or customize risk.
- Common examples include Synthetic CDOs and Asset Swaps.
- They rely heavily on derivatives and counterparty agreements.